The optimal diagnostic imaging strategy depends on the pre-test probability. “For example, patients with a very high probability of CAD may be started on medical therapy, whereas in patients with an intermediate probability additional diagnostic imaging should be performed. In patients with a (very) low probability of CAD, one may consider forgoing additional testing.” CAD Consortium.
Stress testing is best limited to patients with an intermediate pretest probability of CAD to avoid false negatives in patients with high pretest probability and to avoid false positives in pts with low pretest probability (NEJM 1979;301: 230)
KTA: You do a stress test on patients with an intermediate pretest probability of CAD. Patients with a high pre-test probability should be put medical therapy ± sent to catheterization. If the stress test were negative in a patient with a high pre-test probability, you still won’t be reassured that they don’t have CAD because the stress test is not 100% sensitive. So you can skip the stress test in patients with high pretest probability. Patients with low pretest probability may not need a stress test at all.
However, in practice, most PCPs stress test patients with low pre-test probability without referral to cardiology and refer patients with intermediate and high pre-test probability to cardiology. The intermediate pre-test probability patients would definitely get a stress test from cardiology. The high-pretest patients would likely get a cath.
Exercise Stress Testing: Indications and Common Questions.
Table of Contents
Pre-test Probability Calculators
Pre-test probability of CAD (CAD consortium), Calculator. This is more accurate. See AAFP 2017.
Diamond-Forester Pretest Probability for CAD, Calculator. Gives you the pre-test probability as low, intermediate, and high.
The Diamond-Forrester score greatly overestimated the likelihood of CAD and leads to more aggressive and invasive testing.
Things that increase the pretest probability:
- Age: [between 40 and 90 years.]
- Sex:
- Type of Chest pain (Typical, atypical, non-specific)
- Diabetes (Defined as fasting glucose levels of ≥126 mg/dL (≥7 mmol/L) or treatment with either diet intervention, oral glucose-lowering agent or insulin)
- Hypertension (Blood pressure of =140/90 mm Hg or the use of antihypertensive drugs.)
- Dyslipidemia (Defined as a total cholesterol of ≥200 mg/dL (≥5.2 mmol/L) or treatment with lipid-lowering drugs)
- Smoking (Current or past smoking)
- Also EKG changes (Q-waves, or ST abnormalities)
Diamond-Forester Pretest Probability for CAD
**The Diamond-Forrester score greatly overestimated the likelihood of CAD and leads to more aggressive and invasive testing.
Diamond-Forester Pretest Probability for CAD, Calculator.
Diamond Forester Pretest Probability for CAD
Typical Angina: 3 criteria
Age 30-39: 76% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 26% in women (intermediate)
Age 40-49: 87% likelihood (high) in men and 55% in women (intermediate)
Age 50-59: 93% likelihood (high) in men and 73% in women (intermediate)
Age 60-69: 94% likelihood (high) in men and 86% in women (high)
Atypical Angina: 2 criteria
Age 30-39: 34% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 12% in women (low)
Age 40-49: 51% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 22% in women (low)
Age 50-59: 65% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 31% in women (intermediate)
Age 60-69: 72% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 51% in women (intermediate)
Non-Anginal Chest Pain: 1 criterion or none
Age 30-39: 4% likelihood (low) in men and 2% in women (low)
Age 40-49: 13% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 3% in women (low)
Age 50-59: 20% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 7% in women (low)
Age 60-69: 27% likelihood (intermediate) in men and 14% in women (intermediate)
Asymptomatic Patient: Risk is low to very low for both men and women.
Diamond-Forester in table form
Diamond and Forrester Score for Pretest Probability of Coronary Artery Disease | |||||
Age (Years) | Sex | Typical / Definite Angina |
Atypical / Probably Angina |
Non-Specific / Non-anginal chest pain |
Asymptomatic |
30-39 | M | Intermediate | Intermediate | Low | Very low |
F | Intermediate | Very low | Very low | Very low | |
40-49 | M | High | Intermediate | Intermediate | Low |
F | Intermediate | Low | Very low | Very low | |
50-59 | M | High | Intermediate | Intermediate | Low |
F | Intermediate | Intermediate | Low | Very low | |
60-69 | M | High | Intermediate | Intermediate | Low |
F | High | Intermediate | Intermediate | Low |
Definition of probabilities: High > 90%; Intermediate 10-90%, low < 10%, very low < 5%
References
https://www.mdedge.com/familymedicine/article/62640/stress-tests-how-make-calculated-choice Last Accessed 06/2019
Am Fam Physician. 2017 Sep 1;96(5):293-299A. Exercise Stress Testing: Indications and Common Questions. http://www.aafp.org/afp/2017/0901/p293.html
Pocket Primary Care
FPnotebook.com
Am Fam Physician. 2017 May 15;95(10):online. http://www.aafp.org/afp/2017/0515/od1.html
Am Fam Physician. 2011 Mar 1;83(5):603-605. http://www.aafp.org/afp/2011/0301/p603.html